The UK employment landscape is shifting, and with it comes heated debate. The Labour government’s proposed Fair Work Agency, an enforcement body that could take employers to tribunal even when employees are unable or unwilling to do so themselves, has sparked concern. Some critics have labelled it draconian, warning that it hands too much power to the state.
But is this an overreaction? And what does it really mean for employers?
Is the ‘Draconian’ Label Justified?
The word draconian originates from Draco, an ancient Athenian lawmaker known for his excessively harsh legal codes, where even minor offences carried severe punishments. Applying this term to the Fair Work Agency suggests an extreme and unjustified level of enforcement. But at this stage, is that really the case?
The proposed body would only take action where there is a case to answer. It does not introduce new employment laws but rather ensures existing ones are upheld—something that, in principle, should not be a concern for fair and compliant employers.
Should ‘Good Employers’ Be Worried?
A common concern among businesses is that this new enforcement approach could lead to more claims. Some employers, even those who pride themselves on fairness, are wary. But let’s take a step back:
A good employer is one that:
- Pays employees fairly and on time
- Provides safe and supportive working conditions
- Treats employees with dignity and respect
- Adheres to employment laws and best practices
If these principles are already embedded in an organisation, then increased enforcement shouldn’t be a threat. Instead, it should serve as a reassurance that businesses operating ethically won’t be undercut by those who disregard employee rights.
The Cost Concern – A Fair Criticism?
One valid argument is that this enforcement body could increase costs for businesses, particularly SMEs. It’s true that a large corporation with dedicated HR and legal teams will have more resources to ensure compliance compared to a five-person microbusiness.
This is where proportionate regulation is key. The government should probably avoid a one-size-fits-all approach and recognise that small businesses may need additional support. However, at its core, this measure is about accountability. Employers will either have to:
- Pay the cost of unfair treatment (through potential claims and penalties), or
- Invest in proactive compliance – ensuring policies, contracts, and workplace practices meet legal and ethical standards.
The latter is not just a legal requirement but a business advantage.
The Business Case for Fair Treatment
HR professionals and organisations like the CIPD have long researched and championed the benefits of fair and strategic HR practices. When implemented correctly, these practices do more than just protect a business from legal trouble; they actively contribute to growth and success.
- Fair selection practices increase organisational attractiveness for available talent in the market;
- Robust performance management practices increase organisational efficiency by removing blockers and setting employees up for success;
- Tackling bias and exclusionary behaviour can contribute to employee sense of belonging, thus increasing retention; and
- Unethical behaviour in the workplace is reduced by accountability measures and implementation of checks and balances.
These aren’t just compliance measures but smart business strategies that enhance financial performance and long-term sustainability.
What Should Employers Do Next?
Rather than resisting change, employers should see this as an opportunity to review their HR and employment law practices. Now is the time to ensure contracts, policies, and workplace culture align with both legal requirements and best practices.
If you’re confident in your approach, then great! Stay informed by subscribing to our monthly newsletters here
If, however, you’re unsure or concerned, contact us. Being proactive is always better (and cheaper) than being reactive.
How Bhayani Law Can Help
Navigating employment law changes can be complex, but expert guidance can make all the difference. Bhayani Law is a specialist employment law and HR firm that supports organisations of all sizes in ensuring compliance while fostering a positive workplace culture.
We can help you:
- Review and update your contracts and policies to align with current legal requirements.
- Conduct HR audits to identify areas for improvement and mitigate risk.
- Provide expert representation and support in employment tribunal cases.
- Deliver tailored training to upskill your HR team and managers.
- Offer ongoing HR and legal support to ensure your business or charity remains compliant and protected.
By working with Bhayani Law, you gain peace of mind that your business is operating within the law while also benefiting from HR strategies that drive success.
Watertight HR Support for Businesses of All Sizes
Organisations of all sizes can benefit from our Watertight Fixed Fee HR Plan, find out more here. This comprehensive solution is designed to provide cost-effective, expert HR support tailored to your needs. Whether you require ongoing HR advice, employment law guidance, or hands-on support managing your workforce, our plans ensure you have the right strategies in place to safeguard your organisation and promote a thriving workplace.
Contact us today at 0333 888 1360 or email [email protected] to discuss how we can support your organisation through these evolving employment law changes.
